top of page

How big should a promise be?

Nov 5
3 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

In 2018 I promised a friend I would write poems and post them. I promised to write a new one every day. I had three old poems in a drawer that would have done. I posted none of those either. The promise would have suited a poet with a settled routine, but it was too big for me. I told the whole story on Sunday, and today I only want to look at the size of the promise.

Before a promise I used to ask what I wanted to do. Now I ask what I would do with a cold and a deadline. The first question is about my best day. The second is about an ordinary day, and most days are ordinary.

We plan for the days that go well.

Research shows that we plan badly, and that we always get it wrong in the same direction. In the best-known study of the planning fallacy, 37 students estimated how long their final-year thesis would take. Their average guess was 33.9 days. Asked for the worst case, if everything went as badly as it possibly could, they said 48.6. The actual average was 55.5 days, later than their own worst case, and only about 30 per cent finished by the date they had predicted [1]. Those students were not lazy. The study shows that we all plan for days that go well.

The Bhagavad Gita, one of the Hindu scriptures, says that a determined mind is focused on one thing, while an undecided mind is pulled in many directions (2.41). A promise made for your best day starts to break apart as soon as the day turns out to be ordinary. You tell yourself you will catch up tomorrow, do double on Saturday, skip this week or start again on Monday. A promise made for a bad day cannot break apart like that, because it is already as small as it can be.

Halve it, then halve it again.

This is what I do now, before I make a promise, and it takes two minutes.

First, write the big version: “Write a poem and post it, every day.” You need to see it written down to understand what you were about to promise.

Halve it, and it becomes a poem every other day. Most promises survive this and feel fine.

Halve it again, and it becomes one line of a poem in your notebook before breakfast. At this point the promise will feel too small to matter. Ignore that feeling, because this second halving is the one that makes the difference.

Then the test: would you keep this with a cold and a deadline? If the answer is no, halve again. If the answer is yes, that is your promise. It will look embarrassingly small, and a promise you can keep usually does.

If I had made my 2018 promise smaller, it would have been to post one old poem that week. I would have kept that on the first morning, before my bath. I never once kept the promise of a poem every day.

A small promise does not mean low expectations.

Halving a promise does not mean you expect less of yourself. Your ambition goes into how many days you keep it, rather than into each day. One line a day, kept, adds up to a poem a month and a notebook a year. A poem a day, broken on Wednesday, leaves you with three poems and a poor opinion of yourself. The Hindu scriptures use the word sankalpa for a resolve that you make once and keep. A sankalpa is meant to be repeated, and you can only repeat it if it is small enough.

If you’d like to do it on paper, the Size Your Promise sheet walks you through sections one to three on one example: the big version, the two halvings and the cold-and-deadline line.

Tomorrow’s post goes through one day when I broke a promise, hour by hour, without judging myself.

Make your promise small enough for a bad day, and the good days will take care of themselves.

Sources

  1. Buehler, R., Griffin, D. and Ross, M. (1994). Exploring the “planning fallacy”: why people underestimate their task completion times. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67(3), 366 to 381.

Back: Day 26, What does my mind do between the promise and the act? Tomorrow, Day 28, What happened on the day the promise failed?

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Seasonal Friend is a writing service specializing in content strategy, creation and distribution for wellness, spirituality and yoga brands.

Copyright © 2018 - 2026  Seasonal Friend

bottom of page