top of page

Why Doesn't Meditation Work for Me?

31 minutes ago
5 min read

You downloaded the app. You sat on the floor, which hurt. A soothing voice told you to notice your breath. You noticed it for about four seconds, then you noticed your to-do list, then your knee, then the fact that you were failing at meditation, which you'd been told was the one thing that would fix everything else.

After a week you stopped, and you filed yourself under people meditation doesn't work for.

I did this three times before I moved into an ashram. The longest run was a thirty-day focus course in an app. I'd been on day twenty-three for a couple of months. One night I fell asleep halfway through a session, and in the morning I sat wondering whether it counted or whether I should repeat the day.

I wrote an honest report of those twenty minutes. Most of the time went on conversations I would never have with people I would never meet. Most of what was left went on reminding myself to come back to the point of focus. Whatever remained, if anything, was meditation. I wasn't sure what the word meant any more, and I felt equally anxious before and after.

The voice in the app said to trust the process. So I repeated day twenty-three. Again.

Looking back, the wandering and the coming back were the session. What I lacked was everything underneath it. What nobody told me, and what the texts say in the plainest terms, is that I was trying to start on the seventh step.

It's a ladder

Patanjali's Yoga Sutras lay out eight limbs of practice (2.29). Swami Sivananda calls them a ladder, and says in Practical Lessons in Yoga that the student has to ascend it step by step, stage by stage.

The eight, in order: yama, how you treat others. Niyama, how you treat yourself. Asana, the posture. Pranayama, the breath. Pratyahara, pulling the senses in. Dharana, concentration. Dhyana, meditation. Samadhi, absorption.

Meditation is seventh. Seventh. The app had you starting there, on four coffees, after an argument, with the phone face-up on the floor beside you.

Swami Vishnudevananda, in Meditation and Mantras, is direct about this. A proper foundation must be laid before concentration can even be taken up, he writes, and the foundation is built of right conduct, a healthy body, steady posture, breath regulation and withdrawal of the senses. The first five steps form the basis. Only if it's firm will the rest succeed.

What the lower rungs actually do

The first two, yama and niyama, give ethical training and a settled mind. You can't sit still if you lied to someone this morning. The mind keeps going back to it. That's a mechanical point before it's a spiritual one.

Asana steadies the body. Vishnudevananda says concentration is impossible if you're plagued by aching knees and backache. The floor hurt. Of course your mind went to your knee.

Pranayama, he says, removes the tossing of the mind and burns off rajas (restlessness) and tamas (heaviness). We spent a week on this. Restless or heavy before you sit, and the breath is how you change the weather first.

Pratyahara pulls the senses in. Vishnudevananda calls it a kind of fasting for the mind. If the phone is on the floor beside you and the window's open onto the street, the senses are still eating. Nothing's been withdrawn.

Then, Sivananda says, the student is fit for concentration, which comes of itself. Of itself. After the first five, dharana isn't a struggle. And meditation is just concentration that has stopped being interrupted. His definition is one line: an unbroken flow of thought towards the object.

Where this week fits

Look back at the last nine days and you'll see the ladder.

The energy week was rungs three and four, the body and the breath. The posts on scrolling and the wandering senses were rung five. The posts on moods, the four parts of the mind, the five kinds of thought and the knots were a map of what you'll meet when you finally sit. The witness gave a first look at where the ladder goes.

And yesterday's diary, and the post before it on the three stages, are rungs one and two. Sivananda's niyamas include cleanliness, contentment, discipline, self-study and surrender. Clean up is the bottom of the ladder. Which is why I keep saying the order matters.

Why the ladder is good news

I used to find this discouraging. Seven steps before the thing I wanted. Now I find it the most hopeful idea in the series.

It means the ten-minute app session wasn't wasted. It was an attempt to do step seven without steps one to six, and it proved nothing about you. Do the six, roughly, in order, and step seven stops being a fight. Sivananda's word for it was of itself. The texts ask you to arrange the conditions, and the meditation arrives like the clarity on a sattvic (clear, bright) morning. You don't force it. You stop blocking it.

What to do with this

Don't sit for ten minutes tomorrow. Build the five rungs under it first, in a small way, this week.

  1. Rung one and two. Each evening, write the diary from yesterday. Note one person you were straight with and one thing you did for yourself without being told.

  2. Rung three. Find a way to sit that doesn't hurt. A chair is fine. Sivananda says steady and comfortable, nothing more.

  3. Rung four. Before you sit, ten rounds of breath, in for four and out for six. Change the weather first.

  4. Rung five. Phone in another room. Eyes closed. One minute of letting the senses have nothing to eat.

  5. Then, two minutes. Not ten. Watch the mind the way we practised on the witness day. Name what it's doing. When it wanders, and it will, that's rung six being learned.

Do that for a week and see whether the two minutes get easier. Most people find they do, and that they want three.

Another way to look at it

We've been sold meditation as a product you switch on. The tradition treats it as a result, the thing that happens when the rest of your life has been tidied enough for the mind to sit down. That's harder to put in an app. It's also why the people I live with can sit for an hour without apparent effort. They didn't start at seven. They started at one, years ago, and they're still there most mornings.

That's the end of this set of ten. Next, the stages one at a time, starting where Sivananda started: purify.

Where to read more

The Sivananda-tradition books behind today's piece:

  • Practical Lessons in Yoga, Swami Sivananda (the yoga ladder; the lesson on meditation)

  • Meditation and Mantras, Swami Vishnudevananda (the eight steps; concentration in practice)

  • Yoga Sutras, 2.29 to 2.55 and 3.1 to 3.3

If this helped, subscribe to Yogic Productivity on Substack, where the three stages continue weekly from November. And if the storeroom starts opening and you'd like company, an Explorative Letter is a pen friend who writes back.

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Seasonal Friend is a writing service specializing in content strategy, creation and distribution for wellness, spirituality and yoga brands.

Copyright © 2018 - 2026  Seasonal Friend

bottom of page