How do I start again without starting over?
Updated: 5 days ago
This is the third Sunday post. Last week we looked at how to make a promise small enough to keep, even on a bad day. This week is about what to do after a bad day when you could not keep your promise, and how to start again without throwing away what you had built before. If this reached you by email, thank you for being early. This is a long post, and the daily posts this week are based on it.
In this post I share a journal page from September 2024. I wrote it in my seventh week at the ashram, on the day I restarted a book and could not remember why I had stopped. I use it to ask a better question than “How do I get back on track?” Then I look at what the Bhagavad Gita, one of the Hindu scriptures, says about someone who gives up, two studies on why restarts fail and when people restart, and the method I use now. At the end there is a one-page sheet called Begin Again. |
I remember every time I restarted, but never the day I stopped.
22 SEPTEMBER 2024 Restart I had been at the ashram about forty-five days. One evening I opened the book I had been writing, on and off, for years, and started again. The first line I wrote in the journal that night was: “Wow, so it happens again.” I had restarted this book several times before. Sitting there, what I noticed was the gap. I knew I had stopped some months earlier, and I had no idea why. I could not remember a bad day or a decision to stop. The second line was: “But I don’t remember why I gave up.” |
14 JANUARY 2023 The three days I had not missed A year and a half earlier, in a different city, I had opened the journal to write about my new streak and found that the last entry was four days old. “I see here that I have, in fact, missed journaling for 3 days straight without a bother.” I had felt, that whole week, like a man who was writing every day. |
On both pages I remembered restarting, but I could not remember when or why I had stopped.
We restart our habits often, but we rarely look closely at how we restart, because by the time we come back we have forgotten the break. You cannot learn from a stop that you cannot remember, so you begin again from zero and call it a fresh start.
Why can’t I simply get back on track?
For years the question I asked after a gap was “how do I get back on track?” It sounds like a sensible question, but it assumes I knew exactly where I had gone off track. I didn’t, because I had kept no record. So every time, I started from scratch with a new notebook and a new time of day, and every restart was really another first attempt.
Now I ask a different question: what can I keep from last time? This question accepts that the last attempt was not wasted, even if the break makes it feel that way. It also makes you look at what you did last time, such as the half-filled diary or the routine that worked for nine days.
“If I win it once, shouldn’t I be given a permanent pass? Where is the logic? Who designs these games?” From my journal, 5 November 2021, three days after abandoning an entry |
I can count how much the old question cost me in abandoned notebooks. The 25 October post had a page from January 2023 that called a new year’s resolution “my 100th” attempt. Each of those hundred attempts started from zero, because I never carried anything over from the one before.
What do the Hindu scriptures say to someone who gives up?
The Bhagavad Gita, one of the best-known Hindu scriptures, has a whole passage about this. In it, the warrior Arjuna asks his teacher Krishna a very practical question about failure. In chapter six, verses 37 to 39, he asks what happens to the man who has faith and begins the practice of yoga but falls away from it before reaching the end, the yoga-bhrashta (one who has fallen from yoga). Does he lose both worlds, like a cloud torn apart in the sky? Krishna answers him directly:
“O Arjuna, neither in this world, nor in the next world is there destruction for him; none, verily, who does good, O My son, ever comes to grief!” (Bhagavad Gita 6.40, Swami Sivananda’s translation)
The verses that follow (6.43 to 6.44) say that such a person comes in touch with the understanding gained in the earlier effort and is carried onward by that earlier practice, even without meaning to be. I read this as practical advice for an ordinary day. Nothing you practised before the break is lost. The nine days you recorded and the routine that worked are still there, and they will help you if you go back and read them instead of starting a new notebook.
Chapter two says the same thing in fewer words:
“In this there is no loss of effort, nor is there any harm. Even a little of this knowledge protects one from great fear.” (Bhagavad Gita 2.40, Swami Sivananda’s translation)
The verse says that no effort is lost. My restart in 2024 felt like a loss only because I had kept no record of the earlier effort. Swami Sivananda’s daily diary, which I wrote about on Day 23, is what makes this verse practical, because the diary shows you when and why you stopped.
If you are new here: last Sunday’s post used the Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, another Hindu scripture. This one uses chapter six of the Bhagavad Gita, which is about practice and what happens when it breaks down.
“If a restart keeps nothing from last time, it is only another first attempt.” |
Does one missed week really end a practice?
Research shows that a break rarely ends a habit by itself. What ends it is how you think about the first day you missed. The research on relapse calls this the abstinence violation effect: after a lapse, a person who blames themselves, feels guilty and loses confidence that they can keep going is more likely to lapse again, and the lapses accelerate, in the researchers’ phrase, in “an accelerating downward spiral.” [1] Missing a day is just a fact. The downward spiral comes from what you tell yourself about it. Day 25 looked at this over a single morning, and a restart after a long break works the same way.
Research also tells us when people tend to restart, and this has a good side and a bad side. A 2014 study of Google searches, gym visits and commitment contracts found that people are more likely to begin aspirational behaviour at temporal landmarks: at the start of a week, gym visits rose by about 33 per cent and new commitment contracts by about 63 per cent; at the start of a year, searches for “diet” rose by about 82 per cent. [2] The researchers call it the fresh-start effect. This effect is real, and you can use it. But it also explains why we sit on the sofa on a Friday and wait for Monday. A new week makes starting easier, but the waiting is how I lost four days in January 2023.
2.40 The Gita says in this verse that no effort is lost. | 33% Gym visits rose by about this much at the start of a week in the fresh-start study. | 4 days I missed this many days of journaling in January 2023 while I felt I was writing every day. |
You might say that a missed sit is not a relapse and that you are not an addict. That is fair, because the research is about heavier things. But the same pattern shows up with small habits too. You take the first missed day as proof that you have failed, so you start over from zero, and in doing that you throw away the notes that could have shown you what to keep. Last Sunday’s studies still apply: people act on about half of their intentions, and we size our plans for our best day. If you restart without notes, you also plan for your best day, because you are working from memory, and memory remembers the restart but forgets the stop.
So how do you begin again?
This is how I restart a habit now. It takes one evening, and most of that time is spent reading what I wrote before.
1. Read your old notes before you decide anything. Open your diary or the last page of your notebook and read what you wrote before you plan anything. If you have no notes, that is the first lesson, and your restart begins by keeping some. |
2. Write down why the habit stopped, in one line. Take the reason from your notes, because your memory will make one up. You might write: “I stopped the week the morning class moved to six.” Or you might write: “I stopped after missing three days in a row.” If your notes don’t show a reason, write “I don’t know”. An honest “I don’t know” is better than a reason you have made up. |
3. Keep what worked, and change only one thing. You will be tempted to redesign everything, and I would ask you not to. Keep the habit the same size, at the same time of day, and keep checking it in the same way. Change only the one thing that your notes show did not work. If nothing went wrong, change nothing. |
4. Start at your next chance, and don’t wait for Monday. Starting on a Monday or on the first of the month does help, so if one of those is tomorrow, use it. If it is five days away, start today, at the usual time for the habit. |
5. Mark the days you missed, with their dates. Mark each missed day with a dash and its date instead of leaving it blank. Then your notes will show honestly when and why you stopped, and you can read them the next time you restart. |
The rule from the 25 October post, to do the same thing on the day after you miss a day, is a small version of this method. It works for a longer break too. After one missed day, you do the same thing the next day. After a month away, you do the same thing again, with the one change that your notes say you need.
Here is my own example from the ashram. The 41-day practice I finished in 2024 was the first long practice I finished, and I wrote on 25 October that I missed sessions in it. I left out one part. I missed them without changing anything, including the time and the length. The next session was the same session at the same place in the day. I restarted that way every time, and that is why I kept going for 41 days, while every plan I had redesigned before it failed.
WHY I CHANGE ONLY ONE THING Every plan that I redesigned has failed. The one plan that I did not redesign kept me going for 41 days. Redesigning a plan feels responsible, but it lets you avoid reading your notes, and your notes might show that the plan was fine and you were simply tired. When you make one change based on your notes, you are taking responsibility. When you buy a new notebook, you are avoiding the work. |
Here are two ways to restart the same habit.
Here is an example. I have made up the details, but I have seen this pattern many times. Say you have been meditating for five minutes a day, as in the Day 24 post. You keep it up for three weeks, and then you stop for ten days because you are travelling. Here are two ways you could restart.
Day | Restart A: you change everything | Restart B: you read your notes and change one thing |
Sunday | You download a new app and decide to meditate for 20 minutes at 6 a.m. | You read your diary. It shows that you meditated for 19 days and stopped when you began travelling, because you always meditated after making tea in your room. You decide to meditate after washing your face instead, which you can do anywhere. |
Monday | You meditate for 20 minutes and feel proud of yourself. | You meditate for five minutes after washing your face. |
Tuesday | You meditate for 12 minutes, but you resent the early alarm. | You meditate for five minutes. |
Wednesday | You sleep through the 6 a.m. alarm and decide that the app is not working for you. | You meditate for five minutes. |
Thursday | You don’t meditate, and you tell yourself that you are reviewing the plan. | You go to bed late and miss the meditation. You mark it as missed and plan the same thing for tomorrow. |
Friday | You still don’t meditate, and the new plan has quietly ended. | You meditate again. Your diary now shows the first 19 days, the ten days you were away, four more days, one missed day and today. |
Restart A ended on Wednesday, and it left you with nothing to learn from. Restart B is still going, and if it stops again, your notes will show you why.
Restart A really failed on Sunday, even though you only noticed on Wednesday. When you changed everything, Monday became a first day, and we always plan first days for our best possible week. In Restart B you spent Sunday reading your notes, and you changed only the one thing they pointed to.
How does this fit with the first two Sunday posts?
This is the third Sunday post. The 25 October post gave you three steps and a daily diary, and last week’s post showed how to make a promise small enough to keep. This week’s post shows what to do when your diary has a gap in it. The daily posts this week are based on it: why the second attempt feels harder than the first, the first ten minutes back, what not to change, why you cannot remember why you stopped, whether to wait for Monday, and the sheet filled in. The 2024 page is from my seventh week at the ashram; the 2023 page is from a city I left the following January. In the Sunday posts, I go back through those years with what I know now. This is Yogic Productivity, and it is what I write about at Seasonal Friend.
This week’s sheet is Begin Again.
The sheet for this week is called Begin Again (PDF). It is one A4 page for one restart. You write what you kept from last time, why it stopped, the one thing you will change, when you will do it next, and a dated mark for the break. Print it, or draw it on any page.
Tonight, do only the first part: read your old notes. Don’t decide anything until you have read it.
Download: Begin Again (PDF)
What did you keep from the last time you restarted a habit?
What is the practice you have restarted most often, and what did you keep the last time? If the answer is nothing, I would still like to hear it. If you get this by email, hit reply. I read all of them and answer most.
Next Sunday’s post asks why rest makes us feel guilty. It looks at what the Hindu scriptures say about work and rest, and comes with a sheet called Rest With Edges.
The whole post in one paragraph.
We restart our habits often, but we rarely look at how we restart, because we remember restarting and forget stopping. The question “How do I get back on track?” assumes you know where you went off track, and without notes you don’t. The question “What can I keep from last time?” makes you read your notes first. When Arjuna asks Krishna in the Bhagavad Gita about someone who gives up, Krishna answers that no effort is lost and that your earlier practice keeps helping you. You can only see that on paper if you keep a diary. Research shows that one missed day turns into many when you blame yourself and lose confidence, and that people find it easier to start on a Monday, which helps on that day but makes you wait on all the others. So read your notes before you decide anything, write down why the habit stopped, keep what worked and change one thing, start at your next chance, and mark the days you missed. The one practice I never redesigned is the one I kept up. |
Sources
Kirchner, T. R., Shiffman, S. and Wileyto, E. P. (2011). Relapse dynamics during smoking cessation: recurrent abstinence violation effects and lapse-relapse progression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 121(1), 187 to 197. The abstinence violation effect (Marlatt and Gordon, 1985) is “characterized by internal attribution of blame, reduced abstinence self-efficacy, and feelings of guilt”, driving “an accelerating downward spiral”. Open copy: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3296289
Dai, H., Milkman, K. L. and Riis, J. (2014). The fresh start effect: temporal landmarks motivate aspirational behavior. Management Science, 60(10), 2563 to 2582. Gym visits up 33.4 per cent and commitment contracts up 62.9 per cent at the start of a week; diet searches up 82.1 per cent at the start of a year. Open copy: https://faculty.wharton.upenn.edu/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Dai_Fresh_Start_2014_Mgmt_Sci.pdf
Bhagavad Gita 2.40 and 6.37 to 6.45, translation and commentary by Swami Sivananda, The Bhagavad Gita, Divine Life Society. Verses 6.43 to 6.44 paraphrased.
Sheeran and Webb (2016), Buehler, Griffin and Ross (1994) and Lally et al. (2010), as cited in the two previous Sunday posts.
Back: Day 29, How do I write down a promise I can keep? Tomorrow, Day 30, Why does the second attempt feel harder than the first?

Comments