top of page

Why does rest make me feel guilty?

5 days ago
6 min read

On 30 May 2018 I opened my journal with the line “One more attempt to fix a broken routine.” By the time I wrote it I had done my morning pages, been to a workout, finished an article of 1,300 words and written 250 more about mattresses. I added it up on the page and it came to about 3,000 words. Then I wrote that I had exhausted myself and couldn’t go back to work.

On the same page I listed the mistakes that had cost me the day before. The third one was that I kept waiting for sleep and finally slept at around five in the evening. I slept until nine, ate dinner and went back to bed. I wrote, “That’s not the way a productive man should behave.” A few lines later I wrote, “I go to sleep just because I feel like not working. Can you believe it?”

I read that page now and I see a man who wrote 3,000 words and was too tired to write more. At the time I saw a man who sleeps to avoid work, and I made a rule for myself: “I should first finish it and then rest.” The work was never finished, so I never gave myself permission to rest. I rested anyway at five in the evening, and I slept for four hours because I had not decided when to stop.

This post is about the guilt you feel after you rest.

Why did a nap feel like a failure?

For years I asked how I could need less rest. I thought a serious person rested only when the work was done, and I treated tiredness as a weakness I should train out of myself. On that 2018 page I even wrote that I would soon “fix my routine and become a machine.”

Now I ask a different question: what was missing from the way I rested? The evening sleep in 2018 had no start time, because I drifted into it while I was waiting. It had no end time, so it ran for four hours. And I had not chosen it, so I spent the next morning writing about it as a mistake. The sleep itself was what a tired body needed. The guilt came from the way I took it.

The Hindu scriptures treat rest as seriously as work.

People often read the Bhagavad Gita, one of the best-known Hindu scriptures, as a book that tells you to act, and it does say that. Krishna tells Arjuna that action is better than inaction, and that even keeping the body alive is impossible without action (3.8).

But in the sixth chapter, where Krishna teaches meditation, he sets a condition that surprised me when I first read it. He says yoga is impossible for the person who eats too much or eats too little, and for the person who sleeps too much or stays awake too long (6.16). In the next verse he says yoga removes sorrow for the person who is moderate in food and recreation, moderate in effort at work, and moderate in sleep and wakefulness (6.17). I have paraphrased both verses from Swami Sivananda’s translation.

Notice that recreation and sleep are named in the same sentence as work, and all three get the same advice. In these verses, a balanced person measures rest in the same way he measures food. Krishna never describes rest as a reward for finishing your work.

The Gita also describes the two ways this goes wrong (chapter 14). Rajas, or restlessness, keeps you working long after it makes sense. Tamas, or heaviness, keeps you in bed when you should get up. My 2018 page shows both. I worked until I was exhausted in the morning, and I slept for four hours in the evening.

Research says being away from work is not enough.

In 2007 two psychologists, Sabine Sonnentag and Charlotte Fritz, studied what makes time off restore a person. Using answers from 930 employees, they separated four experiences: switching off mentally from work, relaxing, doing something that stretches you, and having a say over how you spend your own time [1].

The first of the four explains my guilt. They point out that being physically away from work may not be enough if the mind stays there. If you spend a nap arguing with yourself about whether you should be napping, your body has left work but your mind has not. The fourth experience explains the rest of it. I had not decided to sleep at five, so I had no say in it, and rest that you did not choose feels like something that happened to you rather than something you did.

You might say that this research is about employees and their evenings after work, and that is fair. I am borrowing the idea and applying it to a nap. But it matches what the Gita says: rest works when you decide on it and decide how long it will last.

My day off used to start with work until midnight.

I live in an ashram now, and Friday is my day off. In October last year I wrote down what my Fridays looked like. The list ended with the words “Rest. A nap. A long restful nap.” Just before those words I had written that I was “always thinking if I should go to the evening satsang and never showing up.” Satsang is the evening gathering for chanting and a talk.

I also wrote that “a true Friday starts on Thursday’s evening.” That Thursday, after satsang, a colleague and I opened the draft of a website we were working on and went through it until midnight. So my day of rest began with work until midnight, and it ended with me wondering whether to go to satsang. I had not decided when my rest would start or end, and I felt guilty at both ends.

So how do I rest without the guilt?

Before you rest, decide three things and write them down. It takes about a minute.

First, write when it starts. “After lunch” is a start. “When I feel tired enough” is how I ended up asleep at five in the evening.

Then write when it ends, and what you will do in the first minute after it. An alarm can end a nap. The bell ends my Friday, because I have promised to walk to the door of the hall when it rings.

Last, write what the rest includes. A nap can include lying down with the phone in another room. My day off includes a swim and the tea shop. If checking messages is not on your list, it waits until the rest is over.

Here is how it looks on an ordinary afternoon. Say you are tired after lunch. You write: “Nap. Starts at 1.30. Ends at 2.00 with an alarm, and then I make tea. Phone stays in the other room.” Then you lie down. When the voice in your head says you should be working, you have an answer on paper. You decided this, it has an end, and the work starts again at two.

When the rest is over, mark it in your diary like any other task. A rest that you planned and took gets a tick, just like meditation or a page of writing.

Does planning rest spoil it?

You might say that rest with a timetable is no longer rest. I thought so too. But look at the alternative on my 2018 page. That rest was completely free. I spent it waiting, and then I spent the next morning calling it a mistake. When you plan a rest, you have already made the decision, and it is much harder to feel guilty about a rest you decided to take.

The whole post in one paragraph.

Rest feels like failure when you take it without deciding to. The Bhagavad Gita puts sleep and recreation in the same verse as work, and asks you to be moderate in all of them (6.16 to 6.17). Research on recovery says time off restores you when your mind leaves the work and when you have chosen how to spend the time [1]. So before each rest, write down when it starts, when it ends and what it includes, and mark it in your diary when you have done it.

If you’d like to do this on paper, use the one-page sheet, Rest With Edges. Fill it in for one rest this week.

After writing 3,000 words in 2018, my body needed that evening sleep. What was missing was a decision to take it and an alarm to end it.

Sources

  1. Sonnentag, S. and Fritz, C. (2007). The Recovery Experience Questionnaire: development and validation of a measure for assessing recuperation and unwinding from work. Journal of Occupational Health Psychology, 12(3), 204 to 221.

  2. Bhagavad Gita 3.8, 6.16 and 6.17, paraphrased from the translation and commentary by Swami Sivananda, The Bhagavad Gita, Divine Life Society.

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Seasonal Friend is a writing service specializing in content strategy, creation and distribution for wellness, spirituality and yoga brands.

Copyright © 2018 - 2026  Seasonal Friend

bottom of page