Why do I break promises to myself?
Updated: 5 days ago
This is the second Sunday post. If it reached you by email, you are one of a small number of people who signed up early, and I am glad you did. This post is long. The daily posts this week are cut from it, so if you only have five minutes, come back on Monday.
In this post, I have put one journal page from 2018, the morning I promised a to-do list that I would love it. I use it to ask a different question from the one I used to ask, which was “how do I become someone who keeps his word?” Then I bring in what the Yoga Sutras and the Gita say about a promise, what two studies say about how badly we size them, and the one thing at the ashram that kept a promise for me when nothing else would: a mantra, one breath long. At the end there is a one-page sheet, Size Your Promise, for this week. |
One morning in 2018 I made a promise to a to-do list.
4 OCTOBER 2018 My broken promises and other truths I had promised a friend that I would write some poems and post them. Nothing came. I could easily have found three old ones and put them up. I didn’t do that either. The page then describes a morning. The to-do list is propped up in front of me, and I make it a promise: today, I am yours. But first a bath, because a man should be clean when he starts. Then breakfast, for energy. Then the room needs cleaning, because nobody can work in that. Then the pencil needs sharpening. Then the head feels cloudy and only a nap will clear it. Then a wash of the face. Then it is afternoon, and there are snacks. “And this is how most of the day passed.” Two lines at the bottom of the page, in my own hand: “How deep is my laziness rooted?” and, underneath it, “The more responsibility I take, the freer I will be.” Then, as if someone else had picked up the pen: “Grow up, Peter Pan.” |
The promise was sincere, but it was too big for that day, and I had made it to a piece of paper.
That is the subject of this post. Last Sunday was about why you can’t count on yourself. This one is about the thing that breaks the trust: the promise you make to yourself and don’t keep. I don’t mean the big public ones. I mean the small morning ones that nobody else knows about.
The size of the promise was the problem all along.
For years the question I asked was “how do I become someone who keeps his word?” I read about integrity. I tried public commitments, apps that fine you for missing a day, friends who would check on me, and a diary with a column for it. Each one worked for about as long as the last one.
I find it more useful to ask what size the promise was. Look at the 2018 page again. The promise was to write a new poem every day and post it. I had made it for a perfect day that did not exist. When I wrote it, I had not written a poem in weeks, and I promised one every day. Yesterday’s post (Day 23) ended with the two kinds of promise that fail: the one too big to keep and the one too small to matter. Almost every promise I have broken was the first kind, and at the time it looked like ambition.
“I don’t have a discipline problem. I have a trust problem. I don’t trust the person who will wake up tomorrow.” A friend of mine, quoted last Sunday |
When you make a promise for your best day, the missed poem matters less than what missing it teaches you. Each broken promise becomes a small piece of evidence against yourself, and after a hundred of them you start to believe it. That is the trust problem from last week, and this is where it comes from.
Patanjali treats a promise as a matter of truthfulness.
Patanjali treats a promise as a question of truth rather than strength. Yoga Sutra 2.30 lists the five yamas (restraints), and the second of them is satya, truthfulness. Sutra 2.36 says that when a person is established in truthfulness, their actions bear fruit; the word and the result start to line up. Read that with a promise to yourself in mind. A promise says what will be true tomorrow: “tomorrow, I will do this.” Breaking it is a small lie. Nobody catches you, so it costs nothing on the day. But the small lies add up, and in the end you no longer believe your own word. That is the person on the 2018 page.
The Gita puts the same thing another way. In chapter two, verse 41, Krishna says that the resolute intellect is one-pointed (vyavasayatmika buddhih), while the thoughts of the irresolute are many-branched and endless. The 2018 list was many-branched. It had a bath, a breakfast, a room to clean, a pencil to sharpen, a nap, a wash of the face and snacks on it. Every branch was a reasonable thing to do. None of them was the work I had promised to do.
Yoga has a word for a resolve of the right size: sankalpa, an intention that you make once and keep. It is not the same as a goal. A goal is a place you want to reach. A sankalpa is one line that is small enough to repeat, and you repeat it. That is the shape the Hindu scriptures give a promise.
I should say what map this is. Last Sunday I gave you three steps, Clean up, Wake up and Grow up, which I adapted from Ken Wilber. This week’s post sits inside the Wake up step, on Patanjali’s map, the yamas and niyamas that come before anything else. The map is different, but the person on it is the same.
“A promise made for your best day breaks on the first bad one.” |
We size our promises badly, and always in the same direction.
Here is the first thing I found out. Studies show that the gap between intending and doing is as large as you might fear. A 2016 review of the research on the intention-behaviour gap concluded that “intentions get translated into action approximately one-half of the time.” [1] That is only half. The review also says the gap comes from people who intended to act and then did not. The 2018 page is a dated example of that.
The second thing is worse, and it explains the first. We size our promises badly, and we do it in one direction. In the best-known study of the planning fallacy, 37 students were asked how long their final-year thesis would take. Their average guess was 33.9 days. Asked for a worst case, “if everything went as poorly as it possibly could”, they said 48.6 days. The average actual time was 55.5 days. Only about 30 per cent finished by the day they had predicted. [2] In other words, the work took longer than their own worst case. The 2018 list was not an unusual failure of character. I had simply made the promise too big, and I was sure the bath would take ten minutes.
about half of intentions get acted on, across the research reviewed in 2016 | 55.5 days actual time to finish a thesis, against 33.9 predicted and 48.6 worst case | 30% of students finished by the date they had promised themselves |
You might say: a thesis is a big project, and my promise is to sit for ten minutes. That is fair. But the direction of the error is the same at every size. We estimate for the day that goes well, and most days don’t. Last Sunday’s figures stand too: if-then plans close part of the gap (d = 0.65 across 94 studies), and a missed day doesn’t break a habit. What this week adds is the size. Deciding when you will act only helps if the promise is small enough to keep.
So how do you size a promise?
This is the way I size a promise now. It takes two minutes, and the sheet at the end of this post walks you through it.
1. Write the big version. Write the promise the way you want to make it. “Write a poem and post it every day.” Don’t shrink it yet. You need to see it at full size to understand what you were about to do. |
2. Halve it. Then halve it again. A poem a day becomes a poem every other day, then one line a day. Sit for an hour becomes thirty minutes, then fifteen. Most promises survive the first halving and complain about the second. The second one is the point. |
3. Run the cold-and-deadline test. Would you keep this with a cold and a deadline? If not, it is still too big for an ordinary day. Shrink it until the answer is yes. The result will look embarrassingly small. That is what a promise you can keep looks like from the outside. |
4. Ask someone or something to check it. Tell one person, or put it on a wall calendar where the ticks and crosses are visible. The 2018 promise was made to a piece of paper that could not look back. When someone or something checks your promise, even a calendar on the wall, it is harder to lie to yourself. |
The restart rule from last Sunday still applies. After a missed day, you do the same thing the next day, and you do not make it smaller. You decide the size once, before the week starts, and you never change it on the morning after a missed day.
Yoga already puts the smallest version of this in your hands. At the ashram, where I live inside Swami Sivananda’s lineage at Neyyar Dam, the smallest promise there is gets kept every evening, by a hall full of people.
ONE BREATH A repetition of a mantra is the smallest promise there is, and it was the first one I kept. There was a period at the ashram when I was badly distracted. What got me through it was not a plan. It was going to the chanting at satsang (the evening gathering) and the evening chanting of the Lalita Sahasranama in the temple. The mantras replaced the chatter in my head, because they left no room for it. The purpose of chanting, as I understand it now, is exactly that: to replace mental chatter with something more useful. Each repetition is a promise the size of one breath, made and kept in the same moment. You cannot break it halfway. You can only start the next one. For beginners the ashram recommends Om Namah Shivaya, a general mantra anyone can chant. When the mind gets used to the mantra and wanders, the breath is the anchor. The one instruction that matters is to be present at the start of every repetition, so that each round is a conscious choice and not a habit. Eventually the sheer number of repetitions takes over, you relax, and the chatter at least goes away. |
That is what a promise made for a bad day looks like. It takes one breath. Nobody writes “chant one round” on a to-do list and fails at it. Wednesday’s post is about the gap between the promise and the act, and what the mantra does in it.
Here is a week in which the big promise fails and the small one lasts.
Here is an example week. I made up the details to show the pattern, but the pattern itself is real. Say the promise is the 2018 one, resized. The big version is a poem a day, posted. Halved twice, it becomes one line of a poem, written in the notebook before breakfast. It passes the cold-and-deadline test, because I could write one line even with a cold. A wall calendar in the kitchen checks it.
Day | Promise as made on Sunday (poem a day) | Promise resized (one line before breakfast) |
Monday | tick | tick |
Tuesday | tick | tick |
Wednesday | cross: a late night, no poem, and the list is now “catch up, two poems” | tick: one line, written badly, written |
Thursday | cross: two poems owed, none written, promise abandoned by lunch | tick |
Friday | nothing: the calendar is not looked at | tick: four lines in a row, and the first full poem in a year |
The big promise ended on Wednesday. I was still keeping the small one on Friday, and the small one produced a poem.
Notice what ended the big version. Wednesday’s miss did no damage on its own. The damage came on Thursday, when the missed poem was added to that day’s list. A promise made for a good Monday turns every missed day into a debt, and debts make people stop looking at the calendar. The small version has no debt. A missed day is only a missed day, and you do the same thing the next day.
This post takes last Sunday’s question further.
This is the second Sunday post, and it takes last week’s question further. The daily posts this week are cut from it: the five-minute promise, the first hour after you break one, what the mind does in the gap, how big a promise should be, one failed day taken apart, and the sheet filled in. The 2018 page is from two years before I first wrote the word Responsibilism, in June 2020, and six years before I moved into the ashram in August 2024. The Sunday posts are me going back through those years with what I know now. This is Yogic Productivity, and it is what I write about at Seasonal Friend.
This week’s sheet is Size Your Promise.
The sheet for this week is called Size Your Promise (PDF). It is one A4 page. The top has space for the big version of one promise. Under that there are two lines for halving it twice, then the cold-and-deadline test, and a line for who or what will check it. The back has a space for each day of the week, where you mark a tick, a cross or a dash, and one sentence at the bottom: After a missed day, do the same thing tomorrow.
Fill in the top tonight, for one promise only. Then leave it alone until the time you chose for tomorrow.
Download: Size Your Promise (PDF)
Which promise have you made most often and kept the least?
What is the promise you have made to yourself most often and kept least? I’d like to know, and I’d like to know what it looks like halved twice. If you get this by email, hit reply. I read all of them and answer most.
Next Sunday: How do I start again without starting over? The morning after the cross, and why most restarts are really a polite way of giving up.
The whole post in one paragraph.
When you promise yourself something, you are saying what will be true tomorrow. When you break the promise, you have told yourself a small lie, and many small lies add up to the trust problem from last week. The Yoga Sutras put truthfulness second among the restraints and say that a person established in it finds that word and result line up; the Gita says the resolute mind is one-pointed and the irresolute one is many-branched, which is a fair description of the 2018 list. The research says intentions get acted on about half the time, and that we size our plans so badly that real life comes in later than our own worst case. So before you make a promise, check its size: write the big version, halve it twice, keep only what you would do with a cold and a deadline, and ask someone or something to check it. After a missed day, do the same thing tomorrow. The smallest promise there is, one repetition of a mantra, is kept every evening by a hall full of people, and it was the first one I kept. |
Sources
Sheeran, P. and Webb, T. L. (2016). The intention-behavior gap. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 10(9), 503 to 518. “Intentions get translated into action approximately one-half of the time” (p. 511). Open copy: https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/107519/
Buehler, R., Griffin, D. and Ross, M. (1994). Exploring the “planning fallacy”: why people underestimate their task completion times. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 67(3), 366 to 381. Thesis study: predicted 33.9 days, worst case 48.6, actual 55.5; about 30 per cent finished by their predicted date.
Patanjali, Yoga Sutras 2.30 (the five yamas) and 2.36 (satya-pratishthayam kriya-phala-ashrayatvam), paraphrased.
Bhagavad Gita 2.41 (vyavasayatmika buddhih ekeha), paraphrased from Swami Sivananda’s translation, Divine Life Society.
Gollwitzer and Sheeran (2006) and Lally et al. (2010), as cited in last Sunday’s post.
Back: Day 23, What should I write in my diary tonight? Tomorrow, Day 24, Why does a five-minute promise work when the hour doesn’t?

Comments