top of page

Why does a five-minute promise work when the hour doesn’t?

Nov 2
3 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

One morning in October 2018 I put a to-do list in front of me and promised to work on it all day. Then I had a bath, then breakfast, then I cleaned the room, then I sharpened a pencil, then I napped, and by the afternoon there were snacks. I told that story in full in yesterday’s Sunday post. I had promised a whole day of work, although I had not written anything for weeks. A whole day was never going to happen, and some part of me knew it, which is why I had a bath first.

On mornings like that, I used to ask why I couldn’t sit down and work for an hour. Now I ask what I would have managed for five minutes. On that day, the answer was one line of a poem, and I would have written it. I didn’t, because I had promised a whole day, and a whole day felt so big that I put it off.

With a short promise, you only have to decide once.

An hour-long promise fails because you have to keep deciding all the way through. You decide to start, and then you keep deciding not to stop. A five-minute promise asks you to decide only once, at the start, and then it is nearly over. By the time your mind has found a reason to stop, the five minutes are done. I have found that on most days I keep going after the five minutes anyway, though not every day.

The Yoga Sutras of Patanjali, one of the main Hindu texts on yoga, say that a practice becomes firm when you keep it up for a long time, without a break, and with care (1.14). Look at the middle condition, “without a break”. Five minutes a day is unbroken. An hour three times a week, when you feel like it, has breaks in it. When the sutra says “for a long time”, it means months and years, and the only way to keep going that long is to make each day so small that you never skip it.

Research supports this. A 2016 review found that people act on their intentions only about half the time [1]. None of the people who failed did so because the task was too small.

Why five minutes works.

My daily meditation is set at five minutes. On most days I sit for longer, and on bad days I sit for five, and five still counts. The promise is five minutes, and anything longer is a bonus. This is where people often go wrong. They promise five minutes but secretly mean thirty, and when the thirty doesn’t happen they count it as a failure. If you promise five minutes, five minutes counts as done.

I live in an ashram where the day follows a timetable, and people assume that makes it easier. What the timetable really does is make the decisions for you: the bell tells you when to start and the class tells you how long. Outside an ashram you have to decide these things yourself, and if you are starting a practice on your own, five minutes is a realistic size.

I don’t see five minutes as settling for less. It works because the task is too short for your mind to put a bath, breakfast, cleaning and a nap in front of it.

If you’d like to try it on paper, open the Size Your Promise sheet and start with section one. Write the big version of one promise, then halve it, and halve it again. Stop when it would fit in five minutes.

Sunday’s post was about making a promise small enough to keep on a bad day. Tomorrow’s post is about what to do in the first hour after you break a promise.

A promise of an hour a day usually fails by Tuesday, while a promise of five minutes can last you the whole week.

Sources

  1. Sheeran, P. and Webb, T. L. (2016). The intention-behavior gap. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 10(9), 503 to 518.

Back: Sunday, Why do I break promises to myself? Tomorrow, Day 25, What do I do in the first hour after I break it?

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Seasonal Friend is a writing service specializing in content strategy, creation and distribution for wellness, spirituality and yoga brands.

Copyright © 2018 - 2026  Seasonal Friend

bottom of page