top of page

Why does the second attempt feel harder than the first?

Nov 9
3 min read

Updated: 5 days ago

In September 2024, about forty-five days into my time at the ashram, I sat down to restart a book I had been writing on and off for years. The first line I wrote in the journal that night was “Wow, so it happens again.” I told the whole story in yesterday’s Sunday post. Today I want to look at why that first line felt so heavy. The first time I started the book, I was thinking only about the book. This time I was also thinking about every attempt that had failed before.

I used to ask why it felt harder now than at the start. Now I ask what I am carrying this time that I did not carry the first time. The answer is a poor opinion of myself. On the first attempt I only had hope. On every attempt after that, I also have my past failures, and if I never wrote them down, I carry a vague feeling about them, which is always worse than the facts.

The Hindu scriptures speak directly to someone who has given up.

The Bhagavad Gita, one of the Hindu scriptures, has a passage for exactly this person. Arjuna asks what becomes of the man who begins the practice with faith and falls away before the end (6.37 to 6.39). Krishna’s answer:

“O Arjuna, neither in this world, nor in the next world is there destruction for him; none, verily, who does good, O My son, ever comes to grief!” (Bhagavad Gita 6.40, Swami Sivananda’s translation)

The verses after it say that such a person is carried onward by the earlier practice, even without meaning to be. It sounds strange to say this to someone who feels they have lost everything, but I have found it to be true of a daily practice. The second attempt feels heavier because you are still carrying the first one. The Gita says the first attempt still helps you, because some part of you already knows how to do it.

The heavy feeling comes from how you judged yourself.

Research explains how this happens. In the research on relapse, one lapse turns into many because of how the person reads it. They blame themselves, feel guilty, and stop believing that they can keep going. The researchers describe the result as “an accelerating downward spiral” [1]. The spiral is built from how you judge yourself, and you usually do that in the first hour after you miss a day, which I wrote about on Day 25.

So the heaviness of the second attempt is real, but you don’t have to keep carrying it. It comes from how you judged the first attempt, and you carry it because you never wrote it down anywhere. A short daily diary, like a three-line version of Swami Sivananda’s, gives you a place to write it down. A missed day marked in the diary is just a fact on a page. Without the diary, the missed day turns into a feeling about yourself, and you bring that feeling to your next attempt.

Reading about your first attempt makes the second one easier.

I have found that the only thing that makes the second attempt easier is reading what you wrote during the first one. Trying to remember it does not help in the same way. When I restarted the book in 2024 I had nothing to read, so all I had was the feeling that “it happens again”. Every habit I have kept since then has a written record. When one of them breaks, I read my notes first. It usually shows that the habit lasted longer than I thought, and that it stopped for a smaller reason than I feared.

Tonight, write only the first line of the Begin Again sheet: what you kept from the last attempt. Take it from your notes if you have any, and write “no notes” if you don’t.

Sunday’s post explains the whole method. Tomorrow’s post is about the first ten minutes of a restart, and what you should avoid doing in them.

The second attempt feels heavier because you are carrying the first one with you, and it gets easier once you write the first one down.

Sources

  1. Kirchner, T. R., Shiffman, S. and Wileyto, E. P. (2011). Relapse dynamics during smoking cessation: recurrent abstinence violation effects and lapse-relapse progression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 121(1), 187 to 197.

Back: Sunday, How do I start again without starting over? Tomorrow, Day 31, What do I do in the first ten minutes back?

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Facebook

Seasonal Friend is a writing service specializing in content strategy, creation and distribution for wellness, spirituality and yoga brands.

Copyright © 2018 - 2026  Seasonal Friend

bottom of page